05-09 On Deleting G-6.0106b and Substituting a New Paragraph in Its Place; on Amending G-14.0240 and G-14.0450; and on Providing a New Authoritative Interpretation.
Source: Presbytery Event:218th General Assembly (2008)
Committee:
[05-09] Church Orders and Ministry
Sponsor:
Boston Presbytery
Topic:Unassigned Type:General Assembly Full Consideration
http://pc-biz.org/Explorer.aspx?id=1461
Assembly Action
On this Item, the General Assembly, acted as follows:
Approve with Comment
Presbyteries are strongly encouraged to consider this overture using a process of listening and discernment.
Electronic Vote - Plenary
Affirmative: 380
Negative: 325
Abstaining: 3
Committee Recommendation
On this Item, the Church Orders and Ministry Committee, acted as follows:
Approve with Comment
Presbyteries are strongly encouraged to consider this overture using a process of listening and discernment.
[Counted Vote - Committee]
Affirmative:41
Negative:11
Abstaining:0
Minority Report
On this Item, the Church Orders and Ministry Committee, acted as follows:
Disapprove with Comment

“The 218th General Assembly directs congregations and presbyteries to use and engage in dialogue around the study guide prepared and released by the Office of Theology & Worship in early 2008 called A study guide for Policy Statements and Recommendations from the 1978 report, “The Church and Homosexuality,” found on the web at www.pcusa.org/theologyandworship/issues.htm

[Not Applicable]
Affirmative:0[**This action has not been verified for accuracy by committee leadership.]
Negative:0
Abstaining:0
Final Text:
In answer to 05-06, 05-08, <span>05-09, 05-11, 05-13
  (Delete or rewrite G-6.0106b, nullify AI)
  To disapprove 05-06, 05-08, 05-09, 05-11, 05-13 with comment:

The 218th General Assembly directs congregations and presbyteries to use and engage in dialogue around the study guide prepared and released by the Office of Theology &amp; Worship in early 2008 called A study guide for Policy Statements and Recommendations from the 1978 report, "The Church and Homosexuality," found on the web at  "http://www.pcusa.org/theologyandworship/issues.htm">www.pcusa.org/theologyandworship/issues.htm
Rationale
 
1. We are concerned about calls to nullify the Definitive Guidance of 1978 when many have not read the document.

2. Furthermore, there is much confusion and misunderstanding about what the Definitive Guidance says.

3.The study had been requested by the 217th General Assembly; but the Office of Theology &amp; Worship was not able to produce the study until earlier this year; and therefore the church has not had a full year to consider its contents.

4. The Definitive Guidance policy statement contains many far-reaching and important guidelines, including strong statements against discrimination and homophobia, and calls for civil rights, dialogue and conversation, and thoughtful reflection from the Scriptures.

Sylvia Dooling, Presbytery of Plains and Peaks
Walter Hamer, Presbytery of John Calvin
Will Anderson, Presbytery of Central Florida
Emily McColl, Presbytery of Los Ranchos
Paul Granstrom, Presbytery of Nevada
David Reimer, Presbytery of Newark
Burfoot Ward, Presbytery of Lake Erie
Ronald Anderson, Presbytery of Pueblo
Warren Wilkewitz, Presbytery of Mid-South
Bobbi Monroe, Presbytery of Kiskiminetas

Assembly committee moderator's statement:

In accordance with Standing Rule E.7.h.(1), I affirm that the position expressed as recommendation for
action by the assembly in this minority report was presented to the whole committee during its
consideration of the matter.

Recommendation

The Presbytery of Boston respectfully overtures the 218th General Assembly (2008) to do the following:

1.   Direct the Stated Clerk to send the following proposed amendment to the presbyteries for their affirmative or negative votes:

a.         Strike the current text of G-6.0106b and insert new text to read as follows: [Text to be deleted is shown with a strike-through; text to be added or inserted is shown as italic.]

“b. Those who are called to office in the church are to lead a life in obedience to Scripture and in conformity to the historic confessional standards of the church. Among these standards is the requirement to live either in fidelity within the covenant of marriage between a man and a woman (W-4.9001), or chastity in singleness. Persons refusing to repent of any self acknowledged practice which the confessions call sin shall not be ordained and/or installed as deacons elders, or ministers of the Word and Sacrament. Those who are called to ordained service in the church, by their assent to the constitutional questions for ordination and installation (W-4.4003), pledge themselves to live lives obedient to Jesus Christ the Head of the Church, striving to follow where he leads through the witness of the Scriptures, and to understand the Scriptures through the instruction of the Confessions. In so doing, they declare their fidelity to the standards of the Church. Each governing body charged with examination for ordination and/or installation (G-14.0240 and G-14.0450) establishes the candidate’s sincere efforts to adhere to these standards.

b.         Amend G-14.0240 as follows: [Text to be deleted is shown with a strike-through; text to be added or inserted is shown as italic.]

“Preparation and Examination for Office

“When persons have been elected to the office of elder or deacon, the session shall confer with them as to their willingness to undertake the office. The session shall provide for a period of study and preparation, after which the session shall examine the officers-elect as to their personal faith; knowledge of the doctrine, government, and discipline contained in the Constitution of the church; and the duties of the office; and readiness to assent to the constitutional questions for ordination and installation. If the examination is approved, the session shall appoint a day for the service of ordination and installation (see W-4.4000). If the examination is not approved for one or more elected officers, the session shall report its action to the congregation’s nominating committee, which shall bring nomination(s) to a meeting of the congregation for any office(s) not filled.”

c.         Amend G-14.0450 by inserting a new paragraph “b.” and by re-lettering current paragraphs “b.” through “d.” as “c.” through “f.” The text shall read as follows: [Text to be deleted is shown with a strike-through; text to be added or inserted is shown as italic.]

“Final Assessment of Readiness to Begin Ordained Ministry

“In the final year of theological education or when a candidate has satisfied all of the requirements of this section, and before the candidate has received a call, the committee on preparation for ministry of the candidate’s presbytery shall conduct a final assessment of the candidate’s readiness to begin ordained ministry. A summary of this assessment shall be reported to the presbytery and shall be transmitted to a calling presbytery when requested. The committee on preparation for ministry shall report to the presbytery when it has certified a candidate ready for examination for ordination, pending a call. This consultation shall focus on the outcomes of inquiry and candidacy and shall include each of the following requirements of certification:

“a. demonstration of readiness to begin ministry of the Word and Sacrament as required to fulfill the candidacy phase of preparation;

b. demonstration of readiness to assent to the constitutional questions for ordination and installation;

b. c.          presentation of a transcript showing satisfactory grades at a regionally accredited college or university, together with a diploma;

c. d.          presentation of a transcript from a theological institution accredited by the Association of Theological Schools acceptable to the presbytery, the transcript showing satisfactory grades, and presentation of a plan to complete the theological degree including Hebrew and Greek and exegesis of the Old and New Testaments using Hebrew and Greek texts;

d. e.          presentation of satisfactory grades together with the examination papers in the five areas covered by the Presbyteries’ Cooperative Committee on Examinations for Candidates.”

2.   Provide the following authoritative interpretation:

Interpretive statements concerning ordained service of homosexual church members by the 190th General Assembly (1978) of the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, and the 119th General Assembly (1979) of the Presbyterian Church in the United States and all subsequent affirmations thereof, have no further force or effect.

Rationale
The opening paragraphs of the Form of Government are a powerful statement of the fundamental Christian and Reformed affirmation that Jesus Christ is the Head of the Church. In support of this primary affirmation, Chapter I of the Form of Government calls Christians to attend to the Scriptures, insofar as they set forth “Christ’s will for the Church,” and Chapter II identifies the church’s confessions as its guides, subordinate to the authority of Jesus Christ and to the witness of Scripture. Our church thus has bound itself to a hierarchy of authority in which we are to obey Jesus Christ its Head, and, additionally, to heed first the Scriptures and then the confessions, to the extent that they accurately bear witness to Christ’s will. This fundamental hierarchy of authority is accurately and eloquently reflected in the first three of the constitutional questions, the assent to which is required of each candidate for ordination and/or installation.

Although the hierarchy of the church’s authority is clear, it is subverted by the current language of G-6.0106b, which substitutes for our obedience to Christ two concepts that are foreign to Reformed understanding: “obedience” to Scripture and “conformity” to the confessions. The proposed amendment would remove this paragraph and substitute new language, which (1) reflects the church’s understanding of where its authority is to be found, and (2) reaffirms the church’s reliance on the examination of candidates by its governing bodies as the principal means by which to ensure the commitment of its ordained officers to the duties of faith. The amendment additionally would insert appropriate language to ensure that each such examination would include discussion of the constitutional questions and the governing body’s determination of the candidate’s readiness to accept their principles and live by them to the extent any of us is able.

In order to be able to rely on Jesus Christ as its Head and as its chief guide in all of life, the church must shed any subordinate source of authority that would bind its ability to follow where he leads. The overture therefore also calls for the rescission of past interpretive statements that have had the effect of limiting Christ’s freedom to use his servants as he would choose.
Comment
Advice from the ACC
Advice on Item 05-09—From the Advisory Committee on the Constitution.

The Advisory Committee on the Constitution advises the 218th General Assembly (2008) regarding Item 05-09 with the following comment.

Rationale

The Advisory Committee on the Constitution refers the 218th General Assembly (2008) to its advice concerning Item 05-01, which sets forth the background that the Advisory Committee on the Constitution believes the assembly should consider in addressing each of the items related to ordination and installation of church officers.

Item 05-09 seeks to delete G-6.0106b from the Form of Government, to substitute a new provision in its place, and to set aside previous authoritative interpretations regarding ordination standards. The Advisory Committee on the Constitution advised the 213th General Assembly (2001), and assemblies since then, that the removal of G-6.0106b alone (or likewise, substitution of new provisions for the existing G-6.0106b) would not alter the church’s position on ordination standards unless the General Assembly also amended or rescinded current authoritative interpretations regarding the eligibility of homosexual persons to hold church office. Approval of this overture would accomplish its intent to modify the church’s position on ordination standards by taking both of the actions the Advisory Committee on the Constitution has advised are necessary to achieve that result.

The proposed language for G-6.0106b substitutes a standard of obedience to Jesus Christ for the current provisions of G-6.0106b. Governing bodies would be given discretion in the application of this standard to particular candidates through the examination process. The proposed language is clear and not inconsistent with any other provision of the Book of Order.

Impact of the proposed revisions to the proposed revised Form of Government before the assembly: To the extent the 218th General Assembly (2008) wishes to make amendment to the current G-6.0106b, the identical provision in the proposed Form of Government is found at 2.0103b.

Other Comments